When it comes to baby diapers, new parents have plenty of choices, from disposable to cloth diapers and everything in between. When it comes to Pampers Swaddlers vs Baby Dry diapers, both are excellent, although there are a few differences.
Swaddlers, for example, have a wetness indicator in all of their sizes, while the Baby Dry only has it in sizes newborn to size 2. Plus, Swaddlers have a cutout for the baby’s bellybutton stump.
Still, there are plenty of similarities between the two, as well.
Both products promise to keep your precious bundle of joy dry for as long as 12 hours and come with stretchy sides for a snug and comfy fit.
Finding the right diaper can be a challenge and I’m sure you will go through at least a few different brands before you find one that works perfectly for your baby.
And even though wondering how many diapers do you really need and it seems like you’re spending half of your budget on diapers now, in a few years when your little one is potty trained, you will be looking back on these days with a smile!
RELATED: Do Diapers Expire At Any Point And What Happens If They Do?
So, read on to get all the details on Pampers Swaddlers vs Baby Dry diapers and to see who comes out on top!
Pampers Swaddlers vs Baby Dry: A quick overview
Pampers Baby Dry diapers:
- promise of up to 12 hours of dryness;
- sold in size newborn through 6;
- wetness indicator that tells you the diaper is wet (only in sizes newborn through 2);
- stretchy sides for a good fit;
- 3 absorbency layers to keep the baby’s skin dry;
- air channels that regulate moisture and spread it evenly;
- reasonably soft;
- slight baby powder smell;
- hypoallergenic;
- sometimes a little saggy.
Pampers Swaddlers:
- promise of up to 12 hours of dryness;
- size range from size 0/newborn to size 6;
- wetness indicator in all sizes;
- stretchy sides for a good fit;
- air channels;
- hypoallergenic;
- feature a cutout in the front for the baby’s umbilical cord stump;
- heart quilts liner on the inside for a super soft feel;
- absorb away liner to keep baby’s skin as dry as possible;
- slight baby powder smell.
Pampers Baby Dry
- Up to 12 hours of overnight dryness
- Locks away wetness into 3 Extra Absorb Channels
- 3 layers of absorbency pull liquid away and keep your baby dry
- 3x drier* for all-night sleep protection *Based on size 4 vs. the leading value brand. Average of 0.19 grams less after 3 typical wettings over 15 min.
Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
Available in sizes 1 through 6, Pampers Baby Dry diapers can fit babies who weigh less than 10 pounds and go all the way to tots who weigh 35 pounds, so they can be your diaper of choice for many years!
One of the most important features of the Baby Dry diapers is the wetness indicator.
It changes colors when the diaper is wet and needs to be changed, which is super helpful for many reasons.
First off, you won’t have to do all sorts of tricks to figure out if the baby needs to have her diaper changed.
So, you can say goodbye to that two-finger test or taking a peek inside to see if there is a mess.
Plus, this makes it a lot easier for a babysitter or another caregiver to know when your little one needs a diaper change.
And I’m sure that new parents who are just learning the ropes of caring for their precious baby will also really appreciate it!
However, the wetness indicator is only included with sizes newborn through size 2.
Another great feature of Baby Dry disposable diapers are the stretchy sides.
Even though the diaper sizes are divided by weight, the fact is that younger babies are just tiny.
That’s why the ability to make sure that the diaper fits snugly is really welcome, in my opinion.
This is especially helpful in cases of blowouts! I’m not saying that these diapers completely eliminate the possibility of the baby’s poop getting absolutely everywhere – because this will happen to you – but it gives you more control over the fit.
When your baby is sleeping in a wet diaper, she can easily get diaper rash.
This happens because a baby’s skin is very sensitive, so when a wet diaper rubs against it, it can really irritate the skin.
Luckily, these Pampers diapers come with as many as 3 layers of absorbency, so the moisture will be locked away from your baby’s skin for much longer than with other diaper brands that aren’t as absorbent.
This makes them a great overnight diaper as they can stay dry for as long as 12 hours!
Since they’re so breathable, they will also do a great job of keeping your little one dry when you’re traveling for longer periods of time and don’t have access to a baby changing table.
There are also air channels that make sure that the wetness doesn’t stay in one place but that the entire diaper absorbs it, which allows your little one to sleep and play comfortably.
When it comes to the material, these baby diapers are quite soft to the touch.
Although, they do have a faint baby powder smell, so remember this if you really dislike scented diapers.
One of the downsides of this diaper is that it tends to sag, regardless of whether it’s full or not.
As any parent will tell you, this can get pretty irritating because the diaper looks like it needs to be changed even when it’s empty.
On the other hand, these diapers are hypoallergenic, so you can rest assured that they won’t cause an allergic reaction.
I love that they come with fun Sesame Street designs – that way, older babies will love it, too!
When it comes to the cost, these diapers are definitely more expensive than the generic ones.
If the price is an important factor for you, I recommend that you calculate how much you’re paying per diaper and not per box.
This is because different sizes don’t contain the same amount of diapers, so seeing how much each diaper will cost gives you a better picture of how much money you’ll be spending on diapers.
As your little one gets older, you will be using fewer diapers per day, which is one of the reasons why boxes with bigger sizes contain fewer diapers than the newborn size, for example.
All in all, Baby Dry diapers are a great choice to keep your little one dry throughout the day and night.
Considering how many parents believe it to be the best diaper brand, you definitely can’t go wrong with giving it a try.
So, to sum up, these diapers can indicate when they need to be changed, can keep the baby’s skin dry, and can be adjusted for a perfect fit to prevent blowouts!
And they’re hypoallergenic, too.
What’s more, if you happen to really love them, you can continue using them until your baby is potty trained, so there’s no need to worry about how your baby will respond to a different brand.
Pampers Swaddlers
- Recommended Weight: 8 - 14 Pounds. No.1 Choice of Hospitals, Nurses and Parents (Hospitals: based on hospital sales data; nurses: vs. other hospital brands, among those with a preference; parents: based on retail sales)
- 2x softer with up to 12 hours of protection (vs. the every day of the year brand)
- Heart Quilts provide our softest comfort ever, while pulling wetness and mess away
- Air Channels allows air to reach baby’s skin to help keep them dry and comfortable
- Wetness Indicator so you know when its time for a change
Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
The Swaddlers range has become really popular in hospitals nationwide – and with good reason! The diapers are incredibly soft and perfect for infants who need their diapers to be as gentle as possible.
They are available in sizes 0 through 6 (just like the Baby Dry) and can even fit tiny infants who weigh less than 10 pounds.
On the other side of the spectrum, the biggest size will fit a toddler who weighs 35 pounds.
As you can see, when it comes to Pampers Swaddlers vs Baby Dry diaper sizes, there is not a big difference and they offer similar ranges based on weight.
While both Swaddlers and Baby Dry have wetness indicators, Swaddlers have the edge here in that it’s available in all sizes.
Baby Dry diapers only have this feature up to size 2, so it’s fantastic that all diapers in the Swaddlers line have it!
You will notice it as a yellow line in the middle of the diaper that will change its color to blue when the diaper needs changing!
This feature is super useful with infants, especially when someone else is watching over them and not quite sure whether the diaper is wet or not.
Apart from making diapering easier, this prevents diaper rash as you will know when the baby needs to be changed, which minimizes the amount of time your little one’s bottom spends in wet diapers.
But it’s good to have with toddlers, too, even though they will sometimes tell (or show) you that they need a change.
Like the above range, Swaddlers offer leak protection through their stretchy sides that allow you to adjust the diaper for a snug yet still comfortable fit.
This ensures that the diaper does not move, no matter how active your little one is, which will give you peace of mind and there will be no need to clean up any messy accidents later!
I also like that the tabs aren’t flimsy and stay in their place, regardless of how much your munchkin moves around!
In addition to the 12-hour protection it shares with the Baby Dry range, Swaddlers includes air channels, too.
These channels make them one of the best overnight diapers on the market, as they protect against leaks and keep the baby’s skin as dry as possible.
These diapers are also hypoallergenic and made from materials that are safe to come into contact with the sensitive skin of babies.
If you have a newborn baby, you will definitely appreciate the little cutout in the front of the diaper for her umbilical cord.
Although there are other ways of preventing the diaper from irritating the umbilical cord stump, such as folding the diaper, it’s much easier when there is a ready-made cutout for this purpose.
A feature that is unique to Swaddlers is the heart quilts liner on the inside of the diaper.
Now, you might think that this is just another marketing gimmick (and usually I would, too, as I’m quite skeptical when it comes to these things), but the liner seriously makes a world of difference in terms of softness!
Plus, the diaper is also super soft on the outside, so there’s comfort all around!
Another thing that sets apart Swaddlers from Baby Dry is the absorb away liner. This liner is responsible for soaking up the wetness and keeping the baby’s skin dry.
But to be fair, all diapers do this (some better than others), so what’s so special about the absorb away liner?
Well, parents have found that it really outperforms other diapers when it comes to locking away moisture – regardless of whether the baby went number 1 or 2 (or both!)
This is excellent news if your little one is struggling with diaper rash.
Some babies are just more sensitive than others, so these diapers are definitely worth giving a try if you’ve been dealing with frequent bum rash episodes.
Swaddlers also don’t sag as much, which is another bonus point.
Remember how I mentioned above that the Baby Dry diapers have a slight scent to them?
You will find that the Swaddlers also have a light baby powder smell, though nowhere near strong enough to give you a headache.
What’s the verdict?
When all is said and done, I do believe that Swaddlers comes out on top in the great Pampers Swaddlers vs Baby Dry battle!
Although it is a very close call, and both have many identical features, there were a few things that tipped me over to Swaddlers’ side.
First off, the softness of these diapers is something to write home about, making them perfect for newborns!
Also, I appreciate the cutout for the baby’s umbilical cord stump – especially for first-time parents who are terrified of somehow irritating it or causing an infection.
I love the absorb away liner, specifically because it prevents diaper rash outbreaks that every parent wants to avoid.
However, I do think both Pampers ranges are excellent quality – it’s just a matter of finding one that works best for you!
What are my other diaper options?
I always try to be mindful of the cost aspect of baby products, so I’d like to recommend Luvs diapers, which are a generic brand.
They are also made by the same company that makes Pampers (Proctor and Gamble), so your little one is still in good hands!
Even though they are more budget-friendly, they can still keep your baby dry for up to 12 hours.
Then, there’s Huggies, which also have a similar timeframe for keeping the baby’s skin dry.
RELATED: Huggies Vs Pampers: Which Diapers Are The Best?
Plus, they are hypoallergenic and some even have a cutout for the baby’s belly button stump.
But disposable diapers aren’t the only way to go!
If you would like to opt for a more environmentally-friendly choice, cloth diapers might just be what you’re looking for.
The tricky thing about cloth diapers is that cleaning and washing them takes much more time than pulling out a disposable diaper and throwing it in the trash when it gets dirty.
Many parents get too excited with the prospect of using eco-friendly, organic diapers or bamboo diapers that they splurge on a bunch of them, only to find that it just isn’t for them.
So, it’s best to take it one at a time and gradually transition to using more and more cloth options.
What’s more, you should be prepared to change these diapers more often than the disposable ones because they can’t absorb moisture to the extent that a Pampers diaper can, for example.
Watch out for counterfeit diapers!
But what’s more worrying is the fact that there is an increasing number of counterfeit baby products available online – and parents have no idea that they paid top dollar for a product that is not the original until it arrives at their doorstep.
When it comes to Pampers Swaddlers vs. Baby Dry diapers, I can guarantee you that if you receive the counterfeit version of either one of these, they will not be anywhere near as good as the real deal.
In fact, they might even be dangerous. For example, they could cause a diaper rash or allergic reaction.
Not to mention that they will probably leak all over the place and cause a giant, unnecessary mess for you to clean up.
This is because “knockoff” products don’t bother to go through any safety testing or quality control, unlike the original product, which is usually owned by a company with a good reputation.
Unfortunately, more and more parents have ended up with counterfeit diapers instead of the original – and some didn’t even notice until they caused an allergic reaction.
One of the ways in which you can protect yourself from receiving a box of fake diapers is to simply shop at the store.
This is a lot less convenient than placing a simple online order but it beats paying full price for diapers that you will end up throwing away!
And if you prefer online shopping, take a look at the product reviews and see if anyone mentioned getting a different kind of product than they expected.
Chances are that a disgruntled shopper probably voiced their disappointment in the reviews section, so don’t skip it!
Also, double-check the product name to make sure that it matches the original one – counterfeit products usually don’t list the correct name.
To sum up
In the great Pampers Swaddlers vs Baby-dry debate, the winner is a very close call!
Both are very high-quality disposable diaper options that can lock in wetness for hours at a time, providing your little one with comfort and protecting her from diaper rash.
In addition, they don’t come with a heavy chemical fragrance that so many parents hate (myself included) and are hypoallergenic so as not to irritate sensitive baby skin.
On the other hand, I did find a few things that I preferred about the Swaddlers, which is why I think they definitely win the Pampers Swaddlers vs Baby Dry diaper showdown.
For example, I love the absorb away liner that seals in wetness and keeps the baby dry.
And the cutout for the belly button stump is a fantastic addition as well, especially for new parents.
In any case, I hope you were able to get all the info you need on these diapers – and good luck diapering!
**If you’re a budget-conscious new mom, make sure to also check out our guides on how many diapers you really need and can diapers expire.
READ NEXT:
- Pampers Cruisers Vs Swaddlers: Which Diaper Is Better?
- Huggies Vs Pampers: Which Diapers Are The Best?
Like this post? Please share or pin it for later. You can also stay in the loop and follow us on Facebook, Instagram and Pinterest.
We love honesty! Find Your Mom Tribe is an Amazon Associate and we earn from qualifying purchases through affiliate links at no extra cost to you. Please see our full Amazon Affiliate disclosure for more information.