Baby carriers are the most practical baby gear for active parents who want to be able to move around freely with their babies.
The Baby Bjorn vs Ergobaby debate is one of the most common in the world of babywearing, as both brands design high-quality carriers with maximum safety and comfort.
Although they share many similarities, there are some key differences that help parents choose which carrier is better for their babies.
Baby Bjorn One and Ergobaby Omni 360 are both great baby products that generally offer the same thing (getting yourself and the baby from point A to B) but in a slightly different manner.
Deciding between the two may seem like a challenging task at first, but after this article, the decision will hopefully be much easier!
Here’s everything that you need to know about each of these baby carriers to help you make the right decision and choose the perfect model for your little one.
Baby Bjorn Vs Ergobaby
Parents want only the best for their children, which often leaves them confused in front of the endless shelves filled with hundreds of baby items that look almost the same.
Finding the best baby carrier for your little one is not an easy task, especially when you have a never-ending choice of various carriers with different characteristics.
Unfortunately, not all carriers are hip-healthy which is why parents have to educate themselves and learn more about babywearing that’s safe for their little ones and their hips.
Ergobaby and Baby Bjorn are two major carrier brands that tend to fulfill most parents’ requirements and they are both capable of following your little one through all of her developmental phases.
Both of these brands have come a long way and the thing I love most about them is that they’re family and parent-owned businesses.
However, there are certain differences between them and today you’ll find out which one is likely to best fit your little one.
Keep in mind that you can’t go wrong with either of these carriers and that this comparison is based on personal preferences rather than general opinion.
Baby Bjorn One
Baby Bjorn is one of the most famous baby brands in the world that offers high-quality baby items that’ll keep you and your baby safe.
The main mission of this family-owned business is to help parents of small children to complete their everyday tasks and routines.
Their story started more than 60 years ago and continues to develop more with the help of parents who share their experiences and experts who are doing their best to create baby gear that’ll be beneficial for both parents and their babies.
With this in mind, Baby Bjorn designed an ergonomic carrier that will carry your little one throughout her early childhood.
Your child will be completely safe in this carrier that’s designed to be used from infancy until the age of three.
Baby Bjorn is also a brand that encourages dads to actively engage in the upbringing of their children by designing baby gear in gender-neutral colors for both parents.
When it comes to the Baby Bjorn Baby Carrier One, this structured carrier is considered to be one of the best models for both the wearer and the baby.
Baby comfort and positioning
The manufacturer has made certain improvements with this model by introducing four carry positions:
• Back carry
This is the first Baby Bjorn carrier that offers a back carry position which is the best option once your little one weighs over 20 pounds.
I’m sure we all agree that carrying a one-year-old can become a real challenge which usually results in severe back pain and long-term back issues.
This model has multiple adjustment points that can modify the size of the carrier as your little one grows.
Baby Bjorn has also managed to create a carrier with a wide seat that doesn’t require infant inserts for additional neck and back support.
The width of the seat bottom enables the child to sit in the correct position at the right angle which is why it’s certified as a hip-healthy carrier by the International Hip Dysplasia Institute.
Baby Bjorn One has adjustable head support, but many parents have noticed that it’s not completely adjustable as it’s higher than most other carriers such as Tula or LILLEbaby baby carriers.
Most parents are satisfied with the softness and comfort of this baby carrier, which includes a breathable mesh material that enables better airflow.
However, if breathability is one of the essential features on your list, I’d highly recommend that you also check out the Baby Bjorn Baby Carrier One Air with 3D mesh that’s soft and comfy, especially for parents who prefer cooler materials.
Parent comfort and positioning
Baby Bjorn One is considered to be one of the most comfortable baby carriers according to parents. No ring slings, baby wraps, or carriers compare to the One model if you ask the majority of parents.
So, why is this model so special? According to those who use this carrier, it’s very comfortable, highly adjustable, and practical.
Parents come in all sizes, just like babies, and it’s not an easy task to find a carrier that can fit everyone equally well, which is exactly what this model managed to achieve.
It comes equipped with padded shoulders that won’t make you look as though you’re from the 80s if you wear it under a jacket and a waist belt that supports your back when you hold the baby.
Although other models from different brands also include waistbands, most of them are not very practical and constantly get in the way.
Another issue with other carriers is that many parents complain about shoulder straps coming off after any kind of movement.
However, Baby Bjorn has found a solution to this issue, as well. This model includes chest clips that ensure the straps stay in place.
Another great thing that may not seem important at first, but actually ends up being essential, is the ability to easily adjust the straps in the front.
One of the best things about this model is that it has the functionality and practicality of a backpack – there’s no need to adjust the carrier with every use.
All you need to do is put the carrier on, place your baby inside, buckle up, and you’re ready to go!
Although the safety buckles might seem a bit too complicated at first, it gets easier with every try and will quickly feel like second nature.
Although this model is machine washable, I’d say the cleaning part is far from convenient because it’s so time-consuming.
Parents have reported that the whole cleaning process takes far too long, as the carrier has to be hung to dry, which takes a lot of time because of the structure, materials, and padding.
This might result in parents avoiding washing the carrier as often as it should be, especially those parents that have to use it frequently.
Nevertheless, Baby Bjorn is still an excellent choice for parents who prefer baby carriers more than strollers and travel systems for everyday use.
The design, all of the features mentioned above, and the quality make this model one of the best baby carriers on the market.
Ergobaby Omni 360
Ergobaby was founded in 2002 when Karin Frost, a young mom, began her own baby-carrying adventure after multiple disappointments with carriers available at the time.
After trying multiple models of baby carriers, she still couldn’t find one that fitted her needs.
After some time, Frost decided to take the matter into her own hands and use her design skills to create a practical and comfortable soft-structured carrier.
Although this design isn’t without flaws, which is completely normal as different parents look for different features in a carrier, it has become the gold standard on the market.
Baby comfort and positioning
The Ergobaby Omni 360 model has surpassed its predecessors with its many improved features, which shows that this brand listens to parents and incorporates their experiences in new models.
You can use this model in every carrying position, including:
• Back carry
• Front carry
• Forward-facing carry
• Inward-facing carry
• Hip carry
Unlike previous Ergobaby carriers, this model requires no infant insert, even for a newborn baby!
Many parents find an insert to be inconvenient.
Parents can now easily adjust the side panels to fit even smaller babies for maximum comfort.
This carrier also follows your child’s development until she becomes a toddler.
However, some parents have noticed that not all babies feel comfortable in this carrier.
Although the seat and sides are padded for softness and coziness, it seems that works only in theory.
Unfortunately, some babies were irritated by the sides and some parents claim the situation got worse as their little one grew older.
On the other hand, this carrier offers a baby hood that provides excellent protection from the sun during long walks, enabling you to start new adventures with your little one!
Just like the Baby Bjorn One, this brand offers an additional model Ergobaby Omni 360 Cool Air Mesh that’s a great option during summer and for parents who live in warmer climates.
Parent comfort and positioning
Unfortunately, the Ergobaby Omni model doesn’t seem to be the most comfortable carrier for parents.
Although it includes several great features, there are some things that parents consider to be big flaws.
This is actually quite interesting, considering that Ergobaby carriers come from a mother who was eager to find the perfect carrier for her child.
What it reveals is that people can really have completely different opinions and requirements.
It’s impossible to find any type of baby gear that perfectly fits all children and their parents.
One of the main issues of the Ergobaby carrier is the overpadding of shoulders which can become uncomfortable.
Even though this model offers a back carry position which is generally a plus, it might not always be the best option for parents.
The shoulder straps might easily end up in your armpits or rub your arms which can be quite painful.
Although the position of the carrier is a bit better during the front carry, it’s still far from perfect, as the waist belt might chafe the lower part of your back (depending on how tall you are).
However, Ergobaby does offer several helpful features for parents, including a removable storage pocket and a privacy hood for easy breastfeeding.
The pocket comes in a decent size, making it perfect for a phone, wallet, toys, or other small items you might need.
The privacy hood is one of the most beloved features for all breastfeeding mothers who can feed their babies even when they’re on a long walk.
This model also includes adjustable head and lumbar support.
All in all, although it might seem a bit complicated to use at first, many parents confirmed that it takes just a bit of practice to use this carrier without any issues.
All parents who have tried out the Ergobaby carrier will agree that this is by far the easiest carrier to clean – all you need to do is put it in a dryer after removing it from the washing machine.
Although some parents say spot cleaning isn’t so convenient as it dries slower than other carriers, I don’t see a big problem there as you can wash it immediately after you get home and then use the dryer.
One of the main advantages is that this carrier can be used for newborns, older babies, and toddlers, and the weight limit goes up to 45lbs.
But, keep in mind that it’ll be almost impossible to use the back carry position without anyone’s help, especially as the little one gets older.
Generally speaking, Ergobaby Omni 360 is far better than any of its predecessors and it contains additional features that the majority of the competition doesn’t include.
However, I do think there’s still room for improvement and I’m more than sure one of the future models will implement suggestions made by experts and parents.
Ergobaby Vs Baby Bjorn – Which One Is Better?
The Baby Bjorn One and Ergobaby Omni 360 baby carriers have many things in common, but most importantly, both brands have the same aim – to create the most comfortable carrier for babies.
Choosing which of these two great baby carriers is best is not an easy task, especially as both models have their pros and cons. Here’s the final breakdown and the winner of the Baby Bjorn vs Ergobaby duel:
Baby Bjorn vs Ergobaby: Baby comfort and positioning
Both carriers have their pros and cons when it comes to the baby’s comfort and positioning.
While both carriers offer basic carrying positions, Ergobaby does have an additional hip carry position, which might be beneficial for some parents.
The Baby Bjorn model might not have an additional position, but it offers various adjustment features for the maximum comfort of your little one as she grows up.
Both models have an adjustable seat that follows the development of your baby until the toddler stage.
However, Baby Bjorn definitely takes the win in this segment, especially because of the uncomfortable padded sides on the Ergobaby carrier that can chafe the baby’s legs.
BabyBjorn is perfect for the baby’s hips as it offers a wide enough seat that enables the right angle and decreases the risk of hip dysplasia.
When it comes to a baby’s comfort and coziness, Baby Bjorn One is definitely the carrier that you need.
Baby Bjorn vs Ergobaby: Parent comfort and positioning
Even though this section is mainly based on a parent’s personal preferences, there are certain general aspects that can be compared.
The thing that most parents appreciate about the Ergobaby Omni 360 is the ability to wear shoulder straps straight or crossed (BabyBjorn doesn’t have this option).
The crossed position provides additional back support, especially in the front carry position (inward or outward-facing).
On the other hand, BabyBjorn is more practical as it doesn’t require any additional help when adjusting the baby in the carrier.
You can put the baby in the carrier while you’re already wearing it, which is not quite possible with the Ergobaby 360 model.
However, what I love most about the Ergobaby is that it has sun protection and a breastfeeding hood, an essential if you ask breastfeeding mothers.
Some parents did have complaints about the waist belt of Ergobaby that rubs their lower back, but I guess that’s more of an individual issue.
Generally speaking, Ergobaby Omni 360 does offer better back support for parents than Baby Bjorn One, although the latter one doesn’t lag far behind.
Baby Bjorn vs Ergobaby: Usage
When it comes to usage, Baby Bjorn One definitely takes the win. It functions like a backpack – all you need to do is put it on and put your baby inside.
Adjustment straps are on the front, which means you won’t have to look for them on your back every time you need to adjust the position of your little one.
Ergobaby Omni 360 is not overly challenging, but it’s definitely not as easy to use as the BabyBjorn carrier.
This is due to the various adjustment features that kind of complicate the whole process of putting your baby inside it.
Both models include safety buckles that might seem a bit difficult to use, but only during the first few uses.
Baby Bjorn vs Ergobaby: Cleaning
Ergobaby Omni 360 is one of the easiest baby carriers to clean. Although almost every carrier, including BabyBjorn, is machine washable, not many models can go into the dryer.
If you own an Ergobaby Omni 360, just put it in the dryer and it’ll be ready to use in no time!
Unfortunately, BabyBjorn will take at least two or three days to dry naturally (which is not an easy task considering all the padding and thick materials).
Although Ergobaby Omni 360 has amazing features that’ll enable your little one to enjoy every walk you take together, I’d have to say BabyBjorn’s One model, because of its overall design and the comfort it offers, is the winner of this duel.
Every parent searches for the safest and most comfortable carrier for their baby, and that’s exactly what BabyBjorn is all about.
It may not have the breastfeeding hood or be capable of drying quickly, but the soft structure and padding will offer your little one maximum comfort and zero skin irritation.
Most parents also confirmed that the BabyBjorn model offers a lot more comfort to them as well without the puffed-up look due to the over-padded shoulder straps.
Of course, this verdict is based on several factors that I found important.
However, if you find other features more relevant, you may prefer the Ergobaby model – the choice is all yours.
How to choose the best baby carrier
Most first-time parents have a mini panic attack every time they enter a baby gear store looking for the perfect carrier for their little one.
However, before you start shopping and discussing which carrier would be better for your child, there are few things you should consider:
• Carrying positions
• Baby comfort and safety
• Overall design
• Parent comfort
Before you choose the carrier, you need to know which positions will work best for you.
For example, if you prefer to carry your child on the hip, you need to find a carrier with that option.
The best way to decide which carrier will fit your baby is to go through these general features and choose the factors that are essential to you.
All you need to do then is exclude all carriers that don’t meet your criteria and you’ll soon find exactly what you’re looking for.
Are baby carriers safe for my baby?
Baby carriers are safe for your child only if they’re used in the right way.
The most important thing to do is follow the manufacturer’s instructions, including the guidelines for weight, age, and height.
Also, make sure you use the carrier properly – check all straps and buckles each time before you put the baby in.
Carriers are a practical solution for long walks, especially for parents who are not big fans of strollers.
However, before you start using a carrier, you need to check which one is safe to use (ergonomic carriers are the only models that are completely safe for a child) and comfortable enough for you (uncomfortable baby carriers can cause serious health issues, including severe back pain).
Baby Bjorn and Ergobaby are two major brands that have come a long way in producing high-quality baby gear.
Baby Bjorn One and Ergobaby Omni 360 are both great carriers for dads and moms that are considered to be improved versions of their predecessors, especially Ergobaby Original which had far fewer possibilities than the new model.
Although they have a lot in common, there were certain factors that determined the winner of the Baby Bjorn One vs Ergobaby Omni 360 debate.
In my opinion, Baby Bjorn One definitely takes the win over Ergobaby Omni 360.
They both have certain pros and cons, but it seems to me that Baby Bjorn’s carrier is a great choice for first-time parents and those who are looking for practicality and maximum comfort for their little ones.
Baby Bjorn is cozier and doesn’t cause irritation to the baby’s skin, while Ergobaby’s sides might chafe the baby’s legs and cause irritation.
However, both of these baby carriers will offer your little one maximum protection and won’t have any negative impact on her healthy development.
Therefore, the choice is all yours, and I’m sure you’ll make the right one!
We love honesty! Find Your Mom Tribe is an Amazon Associate and we earn from qualifying purchases through affiliate links at no extra cost to you. Please see our full Amazon Affiliate disclosure for more information.