The 10 Best Organic Crib Sheets For Your Little One In 2022

Returning to more natural baby items is becoming more and more popular, so choosing the best organic crib sheets should be at the top of your shopping list.

The best organic crib sheets are made from 100% GOTS certified, high-quality organic jersey cotton, fit your crib mattress perfectly, and are tightly knit so they don’t tear.

You might be wondering why you should choose organic over a regular fitted crib sheet, and the answer is in the name, because it’s organic.

While this word gets thrown around all the time, often alongside “vegan” and other modern buzzwords, organic means that the majority of the materials used are eco-friendly, whether recycled or grown and manufactured without being treated with harmful chemicals.

The cultivation and harvest of regular cotton involves lots of different chemicals and pesticides, so it poses a health risk for the farmers growing them, makes the soil less fertile, and poisons the local water supply.

However, it’s not just about the preservation of the environment.

When you choose 100 percent organic cotton crafted crib sheets, you’re getting a product that’s a lot softer than the standard option, and is hypoallergenic and therefore safer for the environment.

That being said, they can sometimes be more expensive than non-organic sheets, so they’re not always the best option for mothers on a budget

This is one of the reasons people tend to avoid them, even if they want to be more eco-conscious.

I am a mom who always chooses eco-friendly diapers and other baby items, and I have been surfing the web and plumbing the depths of Amazon to find you some of the best organic crib sheets on the market, which are also likely to be within your price range.

For all of you busy moms, here’s a quick list of our top picks!

10 Best Organic Crib Sheets

1. Pickle & Pumpkin Organic Crib Sheet

This first option is also one of the most adorable on this list, and one whose quality I can personally attest to as I’ve been using these for my little ones ever since my family’s financial position became more stable.

With the highest thread count of all jersey knit organic sheets currently on the market, the Pickle & Pumpkin organic crib sheet is the most durable crib bedding around.

They come in a standard size, offering a snug fit around the crib mattress so it won’t slide off anywhere or create creases that might be potentially dangerous for your newborn baby.

That’s not all though, because they’re made from 100% GOTS certified organic cotton, which makes the sheets a lot more breathable than the standard variant, as well as ensuring they are free from any harmful chemicals that might agitate the baby’s skin.

They’re also machine washable, and the non-toxic dyes on the prints won’t wash off after a few washes.

Speaking of prints, these sheets have lots of adorable animals that enhance the warm and welcoming feel of the room and add a bit of color to the baby cradle.

They’re also relatively affordable compared to the other options, plus it’s a completely risk-free purchase as the people over at Pickle & Pumpkin offer a 100% satisfaction guarantee or your money back!

2. Magnolia Organics Elephant Crib Sheet

Next up, we have a more simplistic approach to crib bedding, though that doesn’t mean it’s any less charming.

These 100% organic cotton crib sheets from Magnolia Organics also boast a high thread count sateen fabric, making it more durable and less prone to tearing when changing them.

The cotton sateen also makes them ultra soft to the touch and therefore ideal for the sensitive skin of a young child.

These bed sheets come in a bassinet, porta or standard size fit and they’re fully machine washable too.

While they only come in two different color variations, the hand printed elephants are absolutely adorable and are a great gender-neutral option, so you can buy them before you know if your future child is going to be a boy or a girl.

Even their recyclable cotton packaging meets the Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS), meaning that Magnolia Organics always tries their best to reduce their carbon footprint.

3. Burt’s Bees Baby Organic Fitted Crib Sheet

This is another of my favorite organic brands, Burt’s Bees Baby.

They always bring the most eco-friendly products to the market at an affordable price, while still retaining the high level of quality required for young kids.

Their sheets are made from 100% GOTS certified organic cotton that’s lightweight, breathable, and super soft on your little one’s skin.

Their ‘one size fits all’ standard crib bedsteads have thin elastic along the edges to provide a more snug fit, while still making them easy to change when necessary.

This also prevents the tossing and turning of your child from causing the sheets to come up from underneath, as they’re secured with the elastic band.

Of course, these sheets are completely machine washable, just be sure to pay attention to what settings are required so you don’t accidentally wear out the elasticity of the band.

The best part about all of Burt’s Bees Baby products are their prints, as you have so many options to choose from.

They range from a few simple lines to intricate drawings of flowers or the moon, so there’s something for everyone.

They’re also one of the most affordable brands on Amazon and the market in general.

I’d recommend checking them out for their other items as well, especially their eco-friendly kids clothes.

4. Aden by aden + anais Classic Crib Sheet

Another contender for the manufacturer of the best organic crib sheets is Aden+Anais.

They’re made of 100% organic cotton muslin, which makes them an absolute dream for your little one to sleep on, as well as being hypoallergenic and free from any harmful chemicals.

They’re quite breathable too, thanks to the open weave that the muslin contains for better air circulation.

These baby crib sheets fit all standard cribs and mini cribs, offering a snug and secure fit in any situation, preventing potential SIDS (sudden infant death syndrome) due to one of the sides rolling up.

The weave on the sheets allows them to remain as flexible as the day they were bought, even after several washes.

This means you can wash them along with the rest of your fabrics as they’re completely washing machine-friendly.

If that doesn’t persuade you, you might also want to take a look at all the different prints they have on offer for their organic bedding.

One of them is bound to catch your eye, or have something that your kiddo will find absolutely delightful.

5. Magnolia Organics Fitted Interlock Crib Sheet

The budget option from Magnolia Organics has a slightly different, interlock knit with a somewhat lower thread count, but is still a good piece of baby bedding for those of you who don’t have deep pockets and have to pinch pennies where you can.

It’s a bit thicker than a regular bedding set, but is still high quality, albeit slightly tougher to handle.

Naturally, it’s still made from 100 percent organic cotton, and is cruelty-free and only made in factories that respect fair labor policies, while still providing the level of durability that you’d expect from high quality organic bedding.

It is also fully machine washable and will fit any standard sized baby crib, just be sure to follow the instructions for washing so you don’t end up accidentally tarnishing the quality.

Although this budget option replaces all the colorful little elephants with a solid color instead, it’s still not a bad deal as you have a wide variety of options to choose from.

6. My Little North Star Crib Sheet Set

This is a high quality sheet with a simplistic design made by My Little North Star.

While the prints themselves are just gray stars and elephants, they’re still adorable and fit with almost any décor given their neutral color.

Of course, it’s not all about the visual aspect, but how the sheet actually feels.

In this case, My Little North Star spares no expense and all their sheets are made from 100% organic, jersey knit cotton free from any pesticides or other harsh chemicals, and grown on farms that respect their worker’s health just as much as your baby’s.

The material is breathable, hypoallergenic and extremely soft, providing a cozy night’s sleep for your little rascal.

The sheet fits any standard toddler sized mattress and is washer-friendly.

Another thing that might draw you to these sheets, is their 100% satisfaction guarantee, which allows you to either replace the item or get your money back if you aren’t satisfied with the product.

After all, risk-free purchases are a godsend to families on a budget, giving you a bit more room to shop around.

7. QuickZip Crib Sheet Set

QuickZip is an interesting option when considering organic crib bedding, due to their innovative, quick-zip technology.

This is a great option for parents who are afraid of their sheets coming loose and posing a suffocation risk to their little one.

They manage to solve this problem by making a sheet that goes all the way around the mattress.

You might think this makes changing the sheet a nightmare, but the top part of the sheet zips off, making it much easier than you’d expect.

That’s right, the rest of the sheet helps keep the mattress steady and the top of the sheet taut, so no amount of movement from your child will pull it up.

Should the sheet get soiled, all you have to do is unzip it and change it for another one.

There’s no need to pull at the sides of the mattress to fit a regular sheet behind, as it’s just a matter of zipping it back up.

I would recommend placing a mattress pad down beforehand to prevent any heavy-duty leaks from piercing through, though.

The larger sheet that goes underneath doesn’t need to be replaced too often either, just once every few months, or in case of a poop catastrophe.

That being said, you’ll want to look out for what kind of material sheets you buy, because Quickzip offers heavenly soft mink 100% regular as well as organic cotton.

They do tend to be rather pricey, so it might not be the best budget option.

8. Rookie Humans 100% Cotton Sateen Fitted Crib Sheet

This is one of the best organic crib sheets when it comes to design, as their child-like art style really captures the innocence of a newborn baby and provides a friendly and welcoming environment with all the forest friends printed on it.

It has a little bit of color, and the neutral shades allow it to complement almost any baby room design that you envision.

Made from 100% organic, OEKO-tex certified cotton sateen with a thread count of 230, these sheets are durable and eco-friendly, while still being breathable enough to allow air to circulate around the crib properly and keep your baby comfy all year round.

They use a low-impact dying process to ensure they minimize waste during the production process, while preventing any fading even after a few dozen wash cycles.

The only downside is that they’re a bit more of a luxury than the other sheets on this list, but if you ever feel like spending a bit extra, you should definitely give these a try.

9. TEALBEE BABY: 100% Organic Cotton Fitted Crib Sheet

These TEALBEE crib sheets come with an interesting and picturesque design of a nighttime mountaintop forest scene.

It’s an ideal backdrop for taking baby pictures if you also find some matching baby clothes.

That’s not all they’re good for though, as these Tealbee baby crib sheets are made from 100% organic, jersey knit cotton, that never go near a pesticide or harsh chemical.

All their sheets are machine washable and maintain their original softness and color even after they’ve been washed a few times.

They also fit all standard and toddler sized mattresses, so you don’t have to worry about them being too big or small.

They also have a 100% money back guarantee policy to ensure that you’re satisfied with their products, or you get your money back.

10. Natemia Fitted Crib Sheets

If you want a special treat for your kids, then provide them with a couple of these Natemia sheets.

They’re made with 100% pure, jersey knit, GOTS certified, organic Turkish cotton which helps aerate the baby’s sleeping space keeping it nice and cool as well as allowing the child to breathe easier.

The edges of the sheet are lined with elastic, making the fit around the mattress a lot easier and a lot more secure, helping avoid any crinkles that might cause a potential sleeping hazard.

The sheet is fully hypoallergenic, keeping your child’s potential allergies from triggering and ensuring a safe and comfortable sleep.

The sheets are machine-washable and dryable thanks to their quality and durability. They won’t shrink no matter how many times you run them through the cycle.

If you’ve ever worried about getting a proper baby shower gift, this might be the ideal option since every parent will always need more baby sheets.

What To Look For In An Organic Crib Sheet

If you’d rather do your own research on which company makes the best organic crib sheets, then you might want to take some of these factors into consideration.

1. Make sure that the material is organic

When you go online, you’ll be bombarded by “organic this and organic that” all the time, but this is often false advertising.

Make sure to look up the exact material they’re using to ensure that it actually is organic.

If it’s GOTS certified, then it’s a good sign that they’re being truthful.

2. Only get sheets

You’ll often find other crib accessories added into the bundle alongside sheets to sell you a package deal.

It’s not worth it, especially because you’re meant to keep everything else out of the crib for the first year to reduce the risk of SIDS occurring.

3. The sheets need to fit standard-size and toddler-size mattresses

This one is self-explanatory.

Check the exact size of your mattress before buying a sheet, otherwise you could end up with a mismatch, and money wasted on something that you might not be able to get a refund for.

4. The sheets should be machine washable

We’re well past the days where we hand wash items unless absolutely necessary, but if you have a washing machine or use the services of your local laundromat, there’s no point in getting sheets that aren’t washer friendly.

EXTRA: Make sure to get enough sheets

Parents need to have anywhere between 3 and a whopping 10 sheets on hand, depending on how messy their baby gets.

While these numbers are both extremes, if I were you, I’d still make sure to get at least 5-6 sheets just to be on the safe side, so you can always have spare ones handy while the others are being washed.

The Bottom Line

The best organic crib sheets are made by companies that don’t just look to appease the comfort of your child, but also Mother Nature herself and the workers involved in the cultivation of the material and manufacture of the product.

When you make your choice, be sure to pick the company that best encompasses these values and still makes high-quality organic bedding.

I know that some of these options are a bit more expensive than standard sheets, but that’s a small price to pay to raise awareness for environmental protection, and do your part in preserving the world so our little ones can enjoy it in the future too.

Like this post? Please share or pin it for later. You can also stay in the loop and follow us on Facebook, Instagram or Pinterest.

We love honesty! Find Your Mom Tribe is an Amazon Associate and we earn from qualifying purchases through affiliate links at no extra cost to you. Please see our full Amazon Affiliate disclosure for more information.